The Day Forever Died

"The Day Forever Died" by Matt Wertz, from the album Twentythree Places:

Can't believe that you're gone without a trace
I can't believe you got no tears upon your face
While mine is soaking wet
Making up for your lack, I guess
That's how it is in love, or out of love as I sit now
Without you next to me
Wishing things that just can't be

It's all that I can do
Just sit back and watch it all fall through, yeah

It should've been so good, it could've been so right
That was before the day forever died
I'm wishing on "what if's" and taking my chances
That was before the day forever died

Theres nothing left to be said
It's all been spoken
In spite of words you couldn't find for me
I guess you came out ahead
Now I'm broken into a man ashamed to show his face
Walkin' away seemed so easy for you
So why's it gotta be so hard for me?
To see that its over when for so long love was just you and me

It should've been so good, it could've been so right
That was before the day forever died
I'm wishing on "what if's" and taking my chances
That was before the day forever died

Yeah, that pretty much does it.